TurboVets is fully live. For support, please submit tickets in app.
Sign In to TurboVets
Your Data is Protected. Never Sold. Never Used for Profit.
Read our FAQ
5257
§ 4.71a Schedule of ratings—musculoskeletal system.

Knee instability or laxity

The knee is unstable or loose, causing it to give way or feel insecure.

What the rating means

Diagnostic code 5257 covers two separate types of knee instability: recurrent subluxation or instability (ligament-based), and patellar instability. VA rates each type at 10%, 20%, or 30%, depending on the severity of your injury and what a medical provider has prescribed for you to walk safely.

For ligament-based instability, the 30% rating requires an unrepaired or failed repair of a complete ligament tear with persistent instability, and a medical provider must prescribe both an assistive device (such as a cane, crutch, or walker) and bracing for walking. The 20% rating covers either a sprain or incomplete tear with persistent instability where a provider prescribes a brace and/or an assistive device, or an unrepaired or failed complete ligament tear where a provider prescribes one but not both of those aids. The 10% rating applies when any ligament injury causes persistent instability but no provider has prescribed a brace or assistive device for walking.

For patellar instability, the 30% rating requires a diagnosed patellofemoral condition with recurrent instability after surgical repair, and a provider prescribes both a brace and either a cane or a walker. The 20% rating covers the same post-surgical situation but with only one of those aids prescribed. The 10% rating applies when there is recurrent patellar instability with or without prior surgery and no brace, cane, or walker has been prescribed.

Evidence that helps

For ligament-based instability, medical records that document the type of injury matter at every level. Records showing whether your ligament tear was repaired, whether the repair failed, or whether the tear was never repaired help separate the 20% and 30% levels from the 10% level. A written prescription or order from a medical provider specifying a brace, cane, crutches, or walker for ambulation is central to reaching the 20% or 30% level. For 30%, you need documentation showing both an assistive device and bracing were prescribed together.

For patellar instability, records confirming a diagnosis involving the patellofemoral complex are necessary at all levels. Surgical records showing that a repair addressed one or more patellofemoral components are required for the 20% and 30% levels. As with ligament instability, a provider's written prescription for a brace, cane, or walker moves the rating above 10%, and having both a brace and a cane or walker prescribed after surgical repair supports the 30% level.

At every level, exam findings documenting persistent instability, imaging results, and treatment notes describing how your knee functions during walking can help establish the underlying condition. Statements from you describing how instability affects your ability to walk or work may help show the need for prescribed aids.

Secondary conditions

Conditions that are often caused or made worse by this one. If you have any of these, they may be claimable as secondary service connection.

  • Ankle limited motion
  • GERD (acid reflux)
  • Lower back or neck strain
  • Peptic ulcer disease
  • Peptic ulcer disease
  • Plantar fasciitis
  • Thigh limited flexion